A woman and her dog return from their walk to find a red ribbon sticking out of her mailbox, attached is a Christmas card supposedly from her neighbor. Her neighbor comes home one day to find a green ribbon hanging from his mailbox. He opens the box to find the ribbon tied to a reindeer ornament. Confused who left the ornament, he looks around and sees the woman walking down the street. This exchange of holiday items continues until the neighbor musters up the courage to knock on the woman's door and introduce himself. An elderly couple is shown watching from their window across the street, their dining room table littered with craft supplies, including red and green ribbons. Hobby Lobby believes Christmas is what people make it and is offering customers 50% off Christmas items.