Black Friday no longer belongs only to doorbusters and crowded parking lots. It is now one of the biggest events on the retail calendar, online and off. The day’s pull has grown steadily: Black Friday ecommerce sales have more than tripled over the past decade. And how people shop keeps changing. According to Adobe, the vast majority of Buy Now, Pay Later spending on Black Friday 2025 happened on mobile devices, and nearly half of U.S. shoppers said they had used or planned to use AI to help with their holiday shopping.
For advertisers, that creates a hard problem. The same weeks that offer the biggest sales opportunity also bring the most clutter. Every retailer is shouting about deals at once, and viewers learn to tune out a wall of percent-off graphics and countdown clocks. Getting noticed isn’t enough. A Black Friday spot has to earn Attention, hold it, and turn it into Purchase Intent before the shopper moves on to a competitor’s offer.
The creative choices Walmart made helped it break through the Black Friday noise, and those choices translated into the commercial outcome that matters most, the intent to buy. Walmart’s “A Who Knew Carol” campaign took its cue from the 1992 classic “The Muppet Christmas Carol,” reworking the film’s characters, songs, and storyline to showcase how Walmart’s shopping experience has changed. Told in three chapters that are rolling out over the holiday season, the campaign introduces a different ghost into each chapter to convey a specific shopping-focused message. The Ghost of Deals to Come is the one tasked with spotlighting Walmart’s Black Friday and Cyber Monday offers.
Here’s what iSpot’s Creative Assessment platform revealed on actual viewer response to the Walmart spot.

The Details:
- As of Friday, November 20th, 2026, the five most persuasive Black Friday retail ads have been aired by Walmart (two spots), Home Depot (2 spots), and Macy’s (one spot):
- Each of these spots persuaded 61%-63% of U.S. consumers to be more likely to shop with the advertised retailer— a rate that exceeds the average retail ad over the past year by 22% to 26%.
- iSpot’s SAGE Creative AI Agent dove deep into consumer verbatim comments on each of the spots and identified four sentiment themes common across all of these top performers.
- Promotional & message clarity was the volume driver that moved the most people into the funnel with a 32.5% average reach. 74% of these respondents who felt they clearly understood the offer were more likely to act on it. The implication: it is not enough to announce a deal — the ad must make the deal legible and specific.
- Holiday spirit helped amplify Likeability but was not a reliable purchase-intent lever on its own with its Top 2 Box range being the widest (52%-86%) and its average (69%) trailing all other sentiment. Holiday atmosphere is table stakes for this season — it earns goodwill but does not close the loop to purchase on its own. Those specifically mentioning taking action in their comments were among the highest converters (but the smallest group at an average 7.5% of respondents).
- Across all five ads, Brand Affinity converted best (80% intent) but reached a smaller 12.6% of respondents on average — it is therefore a multiplier, not a foundation.
- Each of these spots persuaded 61%-63% of U.S. consumers to be more likely to shop with the advertised retailer— a rate that exceeds the average retail ad over the past year by 22% to 26%.



- Walmart’s :15 “A Who Knew Carol: Black Friday Deals” was a top decile performer across every creative performance metric within the retail category other than Change (which still landed well above-norm):
- The short-form spot managed to deliver outstanding breakthrough (Attention and Likeability) through the characters (Sesame Street and Walter Goggins’ Scrooge) — but not at the expense of the key deal message. The delivery of the promotion led to very high Relevance for U.S. shoppers, 62% of whom reported being more likely to shop the retailer after seeing this spot.
- The appeal was universal with only 3% of respondents complaining of boredom. The creative easily resonated across generation and gender, and left no doubt that Walmart was the advertiser.
- The short-form spot managed to deliver outstanding breakthrough (Attention and Likeability) through the characters (Sesame Street and Walter Goggins’ Scrooge) — but not at the expense of the key deal message. The delivery of the promotion led to very high Relevance for U.S. shoppers, 62% of whom reported being more likely to shop the retailer after seeing this spot.

- Given the four key drivers of Black Friday ad success revealed above, it is notable that four of the five most persuasive retail ads were :15 formats — for this occasion, viewers are in a different mode. They aren’t necessarily looking to be charmed into a brand relationship; they’re shopping, comparing, and deciding where to spend. A :15 fits that mindset. It gets to the offer quickly, states it clearly, and gets out before attention drifts to the next retailer’s pitch or some other aspect of the ad’s content:
- This underscores the importance of clarity as a key Black Friday success driver. Walmart’s :30 cut of the same creative concept delivered a 61% Top 2 Box intent despite double the runtime (vs 62% for the :15). Single Best Thing ratings among each ad’s viewers tell the story — the longer format saw viewers focus to a greater extent on the characters but on balance, the deal/offer and Black Friday messaging slipped into the background.
- However, it is important to note that many of these :15’s don’t work alone. They draw on the equity built by longer flagship spots that have already run. When a campaign like Walmart’s “A Who Knew Carol” has already introduced its characters and story, a short spot can simply nod to that world and deliver the offer. Viewers fill in the rest. The :15 gets the benefit of the longer storytelling without having to retell it.
- This underscores the importance of clarity as a key Black Friday success driver. Walmart’s :30 cut of the same creative concept delivered a 61% Top 2 Box intent despite double the runtime (vs 62% for the :15). Single Best Thing ratings among each ad’s viewers tell the story — the longer format saw viewers focus to a greater extent on the characters but on balance, the deal/offer and Black Friday messaging slipped into the background.


- From 10/25/26-11/19/26, Walmart national linear spend and impressions were heavily concentrated behind two spots:
- The new Black Friday :15 saw minimal support but launched on 11/16, so should be in line for increased support through Black Friday.

During Black Friday, when the decision window is narrow and the competition is relentless, the ads that respect viewers’ time and lead with value are the ones that are moving consumers to intended action.
Ineffective creative, even if delivered to the right audience, results in missed opportunity and performance shortfalls. Great creative delivered poorly also results in failed campaigns.
Schedule a demo to find out how your brand can partner with iSpot to quickly solve both challenges simultaneously, delivering high-performing creative while boosting the effectiveness of planning and in-market execution to achieve—and outperform—campaign objectives.
Creative Agency: Publicis Groupe